| Year | Award Winner |
| 2016 | John Carter (rowing) |
| 2015 | Nick Thomson (soccer) |
| 2014 | Moritz Franz (rowing) |
| 2013 | Ryan Ruikka (ice hockey) |
| 2012 | R.J. Page (track & field) |
| 2011 | Bryon Kallert (swimming & diving) |
| 2010 | Tyler Morris (basketball) |
| 2009 | Dan Schultz (soccer) |
| 2008 | Derek Puerta (soccer) |
| 2007 | John Curry (ice hockey) |
| 2006 | Florian Mennigen (rowing) |
| | Lucjan Zambrowski (track & field) |
| 2005 | Konstantin Voevodski (track & field) |
| 2004 | Brent Bernkrant (swimming & diving) |
| 2003 | Liam Revell (track & field) |
| 2002 | Jeremy Hollander (golf) |
| 2001 | Mike Mallick (swimming & diving) |
| 2000 | Pat Lake (track & field) |
| 1999 | Russell Read (wrestling) |
| 1998 | Karl Rasmussen (cross country/track & field) |
| 1997 | Shawn Ferullo (ice hockey) |
| 1996 | Bernd Trommer (cross country/track & field) |
| 1995 | Jacque Joubert (ice hockey) |
| 1994 | Andre Maksimow (football) |
| 1993 | Michael Carpenter (ice hockey) |
| 1992 | Scott Riewald (swimming & diving) |
| 1991 | Dave Silke (soccer) |
| 1990 | Pat Duthie (wrestling) |
| 1989 | Mike Emenalo (soccer) |
| 1988 | Jack Reybold (football) |
| 1987 | Ricardo Penfold (soccer) |
| 1986 | Brad Hokin (football) |
| | Chris Matchett (ice hockey) |
| 1985 | Ed Martin (football) |
| 1984 | Steve Shapiro (football) |
| 1983 | Declan Hegarty (track & field) |
| 1982 | Bob Green (tennis) |
| 1981 | Dave Bengston (football) |
| 1980 | Steve Wright (basketball) |
| 1979 | Howie Friedman (soccer) |
| 1978 | Rich Laube (track & field) |
| 1977 | Sev Popolizio (wrestling) |
| 1976 | Terry Meagher (ice hockey) |
| 1975 | Bill Burlington (ice hockey) |
| 1974 | Paul Donovan (wrestling) |
| 1973 | David Throne (soccer) |
| 1972 | Steve Stirling (ice hockey) |
| 1971 | Richie Taylor (basketball) |
| 1970 | Larry Davenport (ice hockey) |
| 1969 | Terry Cotton (baseball) |
| | Jay Donabedian (football) |
| | Jim Neviakas (rowing) |
| 1968 | Dick Farley (football/track & field) |
| 1967 | Brian Gilmour (ice hockey) |
| 1966 | Larry Dyer (football) |
| 1965 | Randy Cross (basketball) |
| 1964 | Edward Tantorski (track & field) |
| 1963 | Ed Glinsky (rowing) |
| 1962 | Jim Stack (football) |
| 1961 | Dick O'Connell (basketball) |
| 1960 | John Lawlor (track & field) |
| 1959 | Jack Leaman (basketball) |
| 1958 | Don MacLeod (baseball/ice hockey) |
| 1957 | Charles Fiorino (basketball/baseball/football) |
| 1956 | Thomas Kerr (basketball) |
| 1955 | Tom Gastall (basketball/baseball/football) |
| 1954 | Johnny Nunziato (basketball/baseball/football) |
| 1953 | Paul Whalen (ice hockey) |
| 1952 | Alfred Roberts |
